Free will

[DMB]

This thread is purely to agree a debate. It is not for discussing your ideas about free will. For that please go to this thread (http://www.secularcafe.org/showthread.php?t=11760) in the Philosophy and Morality forum.

Toker would like a debate on whether free will exists or not. He will post here to state what position he wants to uphold.

Please don't post here unless you would like to participate in this debate under formal rules with toker.

If the debate takes place, I will open a peanut gallery where everyone except the participants will be free to comment on the progress of the debate.

[toker]

I say we have free will. There are several positions that disagree. Some of them may be worth exploring.

[columbus]

I say we have free will. There are several positions that disagree. Some of them may be worth exploring.

I already accepted a debate. You didn't agree to get on with it. I'm no longer inclined to keep on with it unless we come to an agreement about the subject. I'll post what I think on the philoshophy thread, and if you still think there is a matter for debate come back here and post that. I'll consider it.

Tom

[toker]

I'm no longer inclined to keep on with it unless we come to an agreement about the subject.
Tom, you've impressed me with your lack of interest. It's kinda weird that you speak up anyway. Show some fire that you have no choice, and I'll damp your enthusiasm. Flare up! Make a stand!

[Monad]

The problem with this sort of debate is it presents the issue as a bipolar one when in fact there are at least 3 different positions.

[toker]

Either we can direct our own behaviors on purpose, or we can't.

[Politesse]

I'll debate the following statement with you: "We are able freely and purposefully direct our own behaviors."

Is this acceptable to you? If "freedom" is not involved, I wouldn't consider the term "free will" meaningful, so the statement as you have set it out above is not acceptable to me. I'm not interested in debating whether or not we have a will, only whether or not it is, in fact, free.

[toker]

You figure that if we have free will, then we could do stuff we aren't actually able to do? I'll pass.

"We are able to purposefully direct our own behaviors." For that I would fight.

[Politesse]

Then you don't believe in free will. I withdraw my offer of debate.

[toker]

The people's angst over the word "free" continues to freak me out. Street lights and thermostats make "decisions", they direct their own behavior, but they don't do it for their own purpose. They do it for our own purpose. They have no choice.

We have choice. We are free to make our own decisions, within whatever relevant boundaries exist.

[toker]

Then you don't believe in free will. I withdraw my offer of debate.
Nonsense, Polly. Maybe I don't buy whatever weird def you peddle, but I advocate free will. Just use a sensible definition. Start with a dictionary, maybe?

[Politesse]

You're free to define "free" however you wish, but I do insist that some definition be used. All you have defined is "will", and I don't contest the existence of will.

[BioBeing]

I don't think toker gets this forum.

[toker]

I don't think toker gets this forum.
If so, it joins a long list of things I don't get.

I think this thread is for setting the parameters of a formal discussion. Your post seems very out-of-place in that regard, as if you don't get this forum. :p

[toker]

You're free to define "free" however you wish, but I do insist that some definition be used. All you have defined is "will", and I don't contest the existence of will.
Will is free will is volition. The ability to make conscious decisions on purpose. I say such ability does exist. Looking for an opponent who claims such ability does not exist.

Street lights WILL change. But they have no choice. People do have choice, and that's why we qualify the term. This isn't rocket surgery.

[Jobar]

I direct your attention to DMB's Staff Note in the OP.

Anyone who is interested in actually debating toker on this subject can notify one of the admins. Until then, this thread is locked.