PDA

View Full Version : UK Science education going down the tubes


DMB
27 Mar 2009, 10:11 AM
http://www.timesonline.co.uk/tol/life_and_style/education/article5983661.ece

It must be really bad for the exam regulator to criticise it!

Many of the multiple choice questions were too easy because the wrong options given were “too obviously incorrect”, it said. There were also too many “short-answer questions that were fairly limited in their requirements or in the scientific content that they addressed”. The GCSE physics paper had replaced the testing of physics concepts with questions about the advantages and drawbacks of CCTV, mobile phones and the internet, it said.

A separate study found a “decline in the standard of performance” in GCSE physics. Papers had got easier because fundamental principles of science were removed from the syllabus.

Read some of the comments at the end of that article. It seems to be part of the "all shall have prizes" mentality. If something is a bit difficult, remove the hard bits.

What I can't understand is that children in international schools can take IGCSE, which has maintained its standards. Many of these children are taking anglophone IGCSEs, even though their first language is not English. And many of the independent schools in England have given up on GCSE altogether. Some don't replace it; others are taking to IGCSE. Similarly, the International Baccalaureate is gaining ground at the expense of A-levels.

ETA: International General Certificate of Secondary Education and IB Diploma Programme

Notta
27 Mar 2009, 12:21 PM
No offense, DMB, but from what I've read recently about A levels and other UK exams, it seems that people are saying they've been dumbed down in recent years, are inconsistent, and do not meet international standards.

Education in the UK and US today are a far cry from what we (people 45 and older) experienced decades ago. So many of our tests and curriculum materials have been made 'student friendly' at the expense of actually LEARNING the content.

The IB program, in contrast, is a high-level, project-based INTERNATIONAL program of study that emphasizes both content and critical thinking skills. We have students in the US that complete multiple AP (advanced placement) courses that are supposed to be the equivalent of college-level introductory courses (but all too frequently are only fast-paced high school courses with lots of homework) who cannot pass an IB course of study. Lots of our schools are switching to the IB curriculum, recognizing that it is a big step above what AP has become.

The international test scores (see PISA (http://www.pisa.oecd.org/pages/0,3417,en_32252351_32235918_1_1_1_1_1,00.html)) show just how badly our students compare to others worldwide.

It's just not the same anymore in either of our countries. Education has been dumbed down across the board, even in our Ivy League universities (more students than ever before require remedial classes when entering college), where students EXPECT to receive an "A" for every class simply for attending.

There are still colleges and universities in the US where high standards exist -- but far too few high schools to prepare students to meet those standards.

Albion
27 Mar 2009, 04:58 PM
Well, if you have a government which wants every child to go to university, and if there are requirements to pass GCSEs and A-levels in order to do it, then the only way forward is to make the exams easy to pass.

On the other hand, while they're dumbing down the science GCSEs and A-levels, they're closing science departments in universities around the country, so I suppose it doesn't matter so much that kids come out of school not really knowing the science, since most of them won't be going on to university science courses.

Doesn't bode well for the need to have a scientifically literate population, though, especially when people don't really understand the subject but have passed a GCSE in it, which means they think they understand it when they don't.

DMB
27 Mar 2009, 06:17 PM
Well they wanted to expand the universities without paying for it. Of course it drags down standards and results in cuts!

HinduWoman
01 Apr 2009, 01:09 PM
Rest assured the situation cannot be as pathetic as in India.

The govt is determined to prove that every child can reach for an university degree --- so the standards at school level and even at colleges are truly horrible.

We get a few elite institutions, but in most cases science is not taught properly.