Food choices

[Coleslaw]

The way this goes, is you post two choices, like "french fries or baked potato". The next person picks the one they prefer and gives the next choice, say "sushi or sashimi", and so it goes.

So I'll start:

sushi or sashimi?

[Christina]

Sushi

Beer or Wine?

[Brianna]

Beer

2% or whole milk?

[Coleslaw]

2%

Indian or Thai?

[David B]

Thai

Cheddar or Stilton?

David

[ofro]

Stilton

red wine or white wine?

[Notta]

White wine.

Beef or chicken?

[Garnet]

Beef

banana or apple?

[PostMortem]

Apple.

Potatoes or Rice?

[Mediancat]

Potatoes.

Fried potatoes or baked potatoes?

Rob

[Brianna]

Baked.

Cheddar cheese or colby cheese?

[ofro]

Cheddar cheese.

Kidney or heart? :D

[hecaterin]

Kidney (yum!)

pineapple or mango?

[Goldie]

mango

Hot & Spicy or Sweet & Sour

[miss djax]

sweet and sour

dark or milk chocolate?

[hecaterin]

Dark, always.

lobster or caviar?

[Coleslaw]

Lobster, but it's a tough choice

Sweet potato or Irish potato?

[DMB]

Sweet potato.

Omelette or soufflé?

[Tawny]

Omelette

Fruit cake or sponge cake

[Garnet]

Blech. Can I say neither? Uh, the lesser of two evils would be sponge cake.

Cake or pie?

[Christina]

Whichever one has the most chocolate.

Italian or Mexican?

[Garnet]

Mexican. (I lived in Arizona for most of my life.)

Chocolate chip or peanut butter cookie?

[Coleslaw]

Chocolate chip

Cajun or Creole?

[Tangiellis]

Cajun.

Sicilian Pizza or a New York slice?

[PostMortem]

Sicilian Pizza.

Honey or Jam?

[4321lynx]

Jam

Orange marmalade or Blackcurrant jam?

[hecaterin]

Hard choice, I'd pick the stronger flavoured/less sweet. Most likely orange marmalade as long as it's Seville orange.

Puppy or kitten? :evil:

[hecaterin]

Oh noes, I killed the thread!

[Cliché Guevara]

lol

Kitten. I like dogs too much to eat them.


Fresh water fish or salt water fish?

[DMB]

Salt water. Much more flavour in general.

Croissant or brioche?

[Garnet]

Croissant. Nom, nom, nom.

Rye or wheat bread?

[Coleslaw]

Rye

Key lime or pecan pie?

[DrLight]

Key Lime


Haggis or black pudding http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Black_pudding

[Notta]

*Urp!*

Haggis.


Raw oysters or steamed clams?

[ofro]

steamed clams

sushi or steak tartare (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Tatar-1.jpg)?

[Christina]

Sushi

Espresso or Cappuccino?

[DrLight]

Cappuccino

fresh squeezed orange juice
or fresh squeezed pineapple juice?

[Mediancat]

fresh squeezed orange juice, but it's a tough call.

Zucchini bread or pumpkin pie?

Rob

[hecaterin]

Having made both recently: pumpkin pie.

It's pizza. Anchovy & olive, or ham & pineapple?

[Coleslaw]

Anchovy and olive.

Breast or thigh?

[Mediancat]

Breast. Definitely breast. I'm definitely a breast man.

I thought this was a thread about food, though.

Rob

[Christina]

You forgot a choice, Rob

Pancakes or waffles?

[Coleslaw]

waffles

Dijon or Creole mustard?

[Garnet]

Dijon.

Mayonaisse or miracle whip?

[ofro]

Mayonnaise

Vichyssoise or gazpacho?

[hecaterin]

Gazpacho. Spicy, nom...

hommous or baba ganouge?

[Christina]

Tough choice, but baba ganoush

Snickers or 3 Musketeers?

[Mediancat]

Three Musketeers.

Durian or vanilla custard in an outhouse?

Rob

[ofro]

Durian
(as bad as it is after the second bite; but never having heard the phrase I simply don't trust the second choice ...)

Thin mints or Samoas

[Notta]

Thin mints! (frozen, of course)

Nattō or bleu cheese?

[miss djax]

bleu cheese, ftw!! natto? eeewwwwww

mortadella or soppresatta?

[hecaterin]

soppresatta ftw.

tea: iced or hot?

[Brianna]

hot

black or green tea?

[Zygote]

black


raw cranberry relish or spiced cooked cranberry sauce?

[Matty]

spiced

Thai Red Curry or Indian Jahlfrezi?

[Brianna]

thai red curry

Moo goo Gai pan or General Tso's Chicken

[Tangiellis]

General Tso's Chicken

vegetable samosa or chicken wrap?

[miss djax]

vegetable samosa

ciabatta or bagel?

[Mediancat]

Assuming plain, ciabatta.

Morningstar Farms breakfast patty, or Boca Italian Sausage?

Rob

[Christina]

Morningstar, but I don't eat them at breakfast time.

Almonds or hazelnuts?

[Matty]

thai red currywrong answer :)


Hazelnuts.

Pop or Milk?

[Tawny]

Pop

Salt and Vinegar or Cheese and Onion

[Brianna]

thai red currywrong answer :)


bite. me.

Cheese and onion.

Cranberry juice or grape juice

[Mediancat]

Cranberry juice.

A vegetarian reuben -- mushrooms, sauerkraut, thousand island dressing, and swiss, on grilled rye bread -- or a Red Robin 5-alarm Boca burger -- Boca patty, pepperjack cheese, jalapenos, tomato, chipotle mayonnaise, on a ciabatta?

Rob

[Coleslaw]

vegetarian reuben, since I don't like pepperjack cheese

penne or ziti?

[miss djax]

penne

burrata or ricotta?

[PostMortem]

Ricotta.

Soba or Udon noddles?

[miss djax]

soba

tuna tataki or ngiri?

[PostMortem]

Tuna tataki.

Butter or Margarine?

[Brianna]

BUTTER!

Olive oil or canola Oil?

[PostMortem]

Canola Oil in the bedroom, Olive Oil in cooking.:p

Rosemary or Thyme?

[Mediancat]

Rosemary.

Pepsi Max or Coke Zero?

Rob

[ofro]

Coke Zero

Lager or Ale?

[PostMortem]

Ale! Ale! Ale! Ale! Ale! Ale! Ale! Ale! Ale! Ale! Ale! Ale! Ale! Ale! Ale! Ale!

Mutton or Lamb?

[hecaterin]

mutton, for the rarety factor.

roast pork or baked ham?

[Brianna]

ham

bacon or turkey bacon?

[Coleslaw]

I rarely eat either, but bacon when I do

Filet or ribeye?

[PostMortem]

Filet.

Squid or Octopus?

[ofro]

Octopus

English/Indian tea or Chinese tea?

[PostMortem]

English/Indian tea.

HP Sauce or Worcestershire sauce?

[hecaterin]

Depends what on, but I'll pick HP.

porridge or cornflakes?

[Notta]

Hewlett Packard makes a sauce??

Worcestershire.

Eggs or oatmeal (porridge)?

(Nevermind....weird about the porridge, though, innit?)

[Mediancat]

I have yet to meet anyone who could make authentic oatmeal in such a fashion that it was tasty all the way through, so . . . corn flakes.

Cheese fries, or potatoes au gratin?

Rob

[Matty]

is poutine allowed as cheese fries?

yeah anyway pooter or chudleys (cheesy chips)

Marmite or Vegimite?

[PostMortem]

Marmite (New Zealand version)

Chocolate vs White Chocolate?

[Brianna]

Chocolate. The darker the better. The more chocolate content the better. HMMMM.

Ketchup or Mayo?

[PostMortem]

Mayo.

Jalapeños or Banana Peppers?

[Brianna]

Banana peppers.

Green Salsa or Red Salsa?

[PostMortem]

Green Salsa.

Carrot Juice or Tomato Juice?

[DrLight]

Tomato juice

croissant or crumpet

[Mediancat]

croissant.

Eggs over easy or over hard?

Rob

[Anne]

easy. I like em drippy.

hot cross buns or danish

[Brianna]

danish

Fried rabbit or squirrel gravy?

[Christina]

*barfs

Carry on...

[Anne]

is squirrel gravy anything like smothered squirrel?

Dammit, I'm a sucker for fried... Fried rabbit.

gummy bears or tootsie rolls?

[sidhe]

Gummy bears.

Mozzarella or sharp cheddar?

[Brianna]

is squirrel gravy anything like smothered squirrel?

Dammit, I'm a sucker for fried... Fried rabbit.

gummy bears or tootsie rolls?


It is squirrel meat in a gravy.

:)

sharp cheddar

yogurt covered raisins or chocolate covered raisins

[sidhe]

Yogurt covered raisins.

Chocolate covered pomegranate pips or chocolate covered ginger?

[Anne]

ew.

[Mediancat]

chocolate coverd ginger.

Ginger ale or Sanka?

Rob

[sidhe]

Ginger ale. Was that even a legitimate fucking choice?

Burger or corn dog?

[Brianna]

BURGER

Salmon or cat fish?

[sidhe]

SALMON!

Catfish or Tuna?

[Mediancat]

Catfish.

Ginger ale. Was that even a legitimate fucking choice?

Burger or corn dog?


They're both foods, aren't they?


Scrapple, or head cheese?

Rob

[dug_down_deep]

I've never seen scrapple, so...scrapple.

Doritos or SunChips?

[sidhe]

Doritos.

Ginger ale or ginger beer?

[Mediancat]

I've never seen scrapple, so...scrapple.

From Wikipedia:

"Scrapple is typically made of hog offal, such as the head, heart, liver, and other scraps, which are boiled with any bones attached (often the entire head), to make a broth. Once cooked, bones and fat are discarded, the meat is reserved, and (dry) cornmeal is boiled in the broth to make a mush. The meat, finely minced, is returned, and seasonings, typically sage, thyme, savory, and others are added. The mush is cast into loaves and allowed to cool thoroughly until gelled. The proportions and seasoning are very much a matter of the region and the cook's taste."

http://www.futilesniff.com/wp-content/uploads/2008/08/scrapple.jpg

Rob

[reddhedd]

ginger ale.

collards or okra?

[sidhe]

collards

mustard or horseradish?

[Brianna]

both. together but horseradish

Horseradish or wasabi

[Christina]

Wasabi

Granola or Captain Crunch with Crunchberries

[reddhedd]

Captain Crunch (if I ate cereal)

cooked or raw carrots?

[sidhe]

Raw carrots.

Cooked or raw steak?

[reddhedd]

vegetarian cooked steak.:D

cornbread or biscuits?

[ofro]

biscuits

raw cookie dough or baked cookies?

[dug_down_deep]

baked

vanilla or strawberry

[reddhedd]

vanilla.

cheesecake or creme brulee?

[hecaterin]

creme brulee.

pumpkin pie or chocolate self-saucing pudding (http://www.taste.com.au/recipes/7789/chocolate+self+saucing+pudding)?

(That was actually my guests' choice last night; most went for both.)

[Tangiellis]

pumpkin pie

apple sauce or oatmeal?

[Coleslaw]

oatmeal

hot wings or nachos?

[PostMortem]

Hot wings.

Regular marshmallows or Camp fire roasted marshmallows?

[dug_down_deep]

camp fire (with chocolate bars and graham crackers, preferably)

Rice Chex or Corn Chex?

[sidhe]

corn chex

Fuji apples or Golden delicious apples?

[reddhedd]

Fuji.

ketchup or mayo with your fries?

[Mediancat]

Ketchup.

Spam, or "Maryland-style"crabcakes from anywhere not in Maryland?

Rob

[dug_down_deep]

Seriously? Um...crab cakes.

fries or onion rings?

[reddhedd]

onion rings.

manicotti or stuffed shells?

[Mediancat]

Seriously? Um...crab cakes.

fries or onion rings?

You must not be from anywhere near MD. It is a point of faith to Marylanders that no one outside the state, with the possible exception of a few Louisianans, is in any way capable of making an edible crabcake.

To the best of my experience, so far, this has proven true.

Rob

[Anne]

I make a killer crab cake.

just saying. Although i do not call mine 'maryland style'. And I've have some awful 'buffalo style' wings.

hmmmm... Dinner after the bbq?

shells

bbq or grilling out?

[reddhedd]

grilling out. Portabello mushrooms, of course.

sweet tea or not?

[Anne]

oooo- bbq ports are to die for.

normal tea, thank you.

root beer or cola?

[sidhe]

I also make a killer crab cake. I learned from a grandmother from Maryland. Not my grandmother, though. Someone else's granny.

Root beer.

Red Bull or vodka?

[reddhedd]

What's "normal tea"? Where I come from, iced tea comes sweet unless you ask for not sweet.

vodka.

tequila...room temp or chilled?

[4321lynx]

room temperature (if drunk neat ie straight) Iced in mixed drinks.

Finlandia vodka or Gray goose?

[Notta]

Gray goose.

Decaf or caffeinated? (doesn't matter what the carrying liquid is)

[Anne]

with lead.

lamb or ham

[Coleslaw]

lamb

bacon or sausage?

[PostMortem]

Sausage.

Lentils or Beans?

[reddhedd]

beans.

whole wheat bread or white?

[Anne]

whole wheat.

cream or milk in coffee?

[PostMortem]

Cream.

Sugar or Sugar substitute in your coffee?

[sidhe]

Sugar substitute...all natural agave nectar. :)

Honey or sugar?

[reddhedd]

Honey. (or all natural agave nectar. :D)

raspberries or blackberries?

[dug_down_deep]

blackberries (or black raspberries, even better)

(Taco Bell) fire sauce or mild sauce?

[Mediancat]

Fire sauce.

Jolt Cola or Pepsi Max?

Rob

[Anne]

Jolt.

breaded <shudder> or naked (real) (Buffalo) wings?

[4321lynx]

Real. (Kissing Bridge made good ones at one time) :)

Pirrhi-pirrhi chicken or shrimp?

[Mediancat]

Shrimp.

Three-egg vegetarian omelet, or eggs benedict?

Rob

[ofro]

Eggs benedict.

sauce hollandaise or sauce béarnaise?

[reddhedd]

Mmm, hollandaise.

potato salad or macaroni salad?

[Brianna]

potato salad

tuna fish salad sandwiches or ground bologna sandwiches?

[hecaterin]

tuna

doughnuts: hot cinnamon sugar, or cold iced with sprinkles

[Zygote]

hot cinnamon sugar


ranch or vinaigrette?

[sidhe]

Ranch.

Tzatziki or Feta dip?

[Notta]

Tzatziki

Fried fair food or 5-star French restaurant?

[sidhe]

5-star French food batter-dipped and deep-fried.

Haggis or spotted dick?

[ninewands]

<deleted>

[Daisy]

Spotted dick.

Sweetbread or sweet bread?

[sidhe]

Hmm...I've always wanted to try sweetbreads, and I can make my own sweet bread whenever...so sweetbreads.

Raw oysters or Rocky Mountain oysters?

[Brianna]

rocky mountain oysters. just cause some people should like sucking on balls!

Spotted Cow or Fat Tire?

[sidhe]

I'll go with Fat Tire, simply because Fat Tire Brewing is adding GA as a territory this year, so I'll get to frakkin' drink it soon. New Glarus' Spotted Cow? Not so much.

Arrogant Bastard or Terrapin Rye?

[ofro]

Arrogant Bastard
(but I drink much TR more often)

90 Minutes or Anchor Steam?

[sidhe]

Anchor Steam IPA

Bushmill's or Jameson's?

[Brianna]

Jameson's Neat

Tullamore Dew or Jameson's?

[Tawny]

Jamesons

Pasta or Pizza

[sidhe]

Pizza

JD Neat or JD & Coke?

[Tawny]

Neat

Diet coke or Normal Coke?

[Brianna]

Pizza

JD Neat or JD & Coke?

JD IS NOT WHISKEY. It is horse piss in a bottle.

Diet coke

Coffee or Tea?

[Tawny]

Tea, I am english!

Still or sparkling water

[Mediancat]

Still. Still waters run deep, after all.

Moxie or Vernor's?

Rob

[Brianna]

Tea, I am english!

Still or sparkling water

Still?

I am guessing you don't mean tap water.

[sidhe]

Pizza

JD Neat or JD & Coke?

JD IS NOT WHISKEY. It is horse piss in a bottle.

Half-correct! JD is Tennessee whiskey, which isn't like any other variety on earth, so if you like Irish, Scotch, or even Bourbon, you won't like JD.

I, for instance, don't like JD. Too frakkin' sweet.

Still. Still waters run deep, after all.

Moxie or Vernor's?

Rob

Vernor's.

Mint tea or chamomile tea?

[Tawny]

Tea, I am english!

Still or sparkling water

Still?

I am guessing you don't mean tap water.
I meant bottled......

[Matty]

there is no difference y'know? :)

Chamomile tea is slightly less minging than mint i guess so that one.


Scotch or Rum.

[sidhe]

Scotch. Blah on rum.

Chocolate chip cookies or peanut butter cookies?

[reddhedd]

chocolate chip.

M&Ms or Reese's?

[Zygote]

Reese's


Cheerios or Corn Flakes?

[sidhe]

Cheerios...either with milk or prepared by an old family recipe to make a savory dish of cheerios...

Chex mix or Gardetto's?

[miss djax]

gardetto's

candy corn or cotton candy?

[sidhe]

candy corn

kettle corn or buttered popcorn?

[Coleslaw]

Kettle corn

fish tacos or chicken tacos?

[4321lynx]

Neither.

Fajitas or quesadillas?

[ofro]

Fajitas.

Basmati or Lotus rice?

[hecaterin]

I googled it, and it looks like Lotus is a brand name, not a variety of rice. In Australia, they distribute Basmati, Jasmine and an unnamed variety of long grain rice, in both white and brown.

So, err, I'll take Basmati.

peanut butter: crunchy or smooth?

[reddhedd]

crunchy.

crunchy tacos or soft?

[sidhe]

Soft, in corn tortillas.

Fajitas or alambres?

[Mediancat]

Fajitas.

Circus Peanuts or Coconut marshmallows?

Rob

[reddhedd]

Circus peanuts.

peanuts...boiled or roasted?

[miss djax]

roasted

pringles or dorito's?

[Mediancat]

Doritos. If forced to choose.

Hard or soft pretzels?

Rob

[nygreenguy]

Doritos. If forced to choose.

Hard or soft pretzels?

Rob


Soft. Hard pretzels are barf-tastic

Chocolate shake or chocolate malt?

[sidhe]

Chocolate malt.

Chocolate and peanut butter or chocolate and mint?

[dug_down_deep]

Tough one, but...peanut butter.

Caramel or butterscotch?

[sidhe]

Caramel

Raisins or chocolate chips?

[4321lynx]

Raisins


White or red grapes?

[reddhedd]

white.

Morningstar Farms, or Boca?

[Matty]

Steak :)

same question.

[miss djax]

steak and morningstar farms :D

linguica or chorizo?

[Matty]

i suppose some of their stuff might suffice as a side dish, true :)
Chorizo,a real paprica-y one.

Bacon sarnie or Egg McMuffin?

[Brianna]

huh?

Neither, but if i had to pick BACON sarnie (whatever that is)

vodka and 7up or vodka and oj?

[Zygote]

vodka and oj

Cabernet or Chardonnay?

[4321lynx]

Both.

Rioja or Bordeaux?

(& btw Brianna vodka and 7up or vodka and oj?
This is heresy, sacrilege, blasphemy. Off with her head!!!:)
Vodka, straight, "knocked back" NOT sipped, followed by soused (salted) herring on black bread, followed by vodka, followed by more herring, followed by vodka, followed by... well, you get the idea. Unless of course you can afford and can find, caviar on bliny +/- sour cream &/or butter instead of the poor bloody herring. Even vodka in a Bloody Mary is a bad choice Use Tequila & call it a Bloody Maria.)

Edit I have found German red or black lumpfish "caviar" over Philadelphia cream cheese a pleasant cheap substitute for the real thing, which is unobtainable where I live. And if all the salty stuff makes you thirsty, drink beer as a chaser. All the fat in the zakuski will keep you sober & your stomach uninflamed for quite some time. :D

[sidhe]

Bordeaux

Sushi or sashimi?

[Matty]

Sashimi.


Red or Green Curry.

[sidhe]

Green curry.

Salsa verde or salsa roja?

[Matty]

verde.


Liver and Onions or Steak and Kidney Pie?

[Sodong]

steak and kidney...uuhhhh http://planetsmilies.net/obscene-smiley-991.gif (http://planetsmilies.net)

double cream brie or havarti?

[reddhedd]

Mmm ..Brie...

saltines or ritz crackers?

[Matty]

no idea what saltines are so i'll take the Ritz i guess.

mature cheddar or a well aged stilton?

[4321lynx]

Stilton


Roquefort or Bleu de Bresse?

[Sodong]

Roquefort.

A "Saltine" is a soda cracker, Matty.

Hot and Sour or Pho?

[sidhe]

Pho

Pad Thai or Mu Shu Chicken?

[hecaterin]

Pad Thai.

eggs benedict or florentine?

[sidhe]

eggs benedict

Biscuit or croissant?

[Mediancat]

Biscuit. Especially if my dad makes them.

Boysenberry yogurt, or cinnamon-raisin rice pudding?

ROb

[Matty]

can i have the rice pudding wirthout the shite in it pls?
I'll take that anyway not knowing what a boysenberry is, you lot and your USIan exclusive foods.


Heres a get your own back for the brits.

Rich Tea or Hob Nobs? (beware the answer will tell everyone one how accomplished a biscuit dunker you are :))

[Sodong]

Biscuit. Especially if my dad makes them.

Boysenberry yogurt, or cinnamon-raisin rice pudding?

RObCinnamon-raisin rice pudding though I like to put a couple of cardamom pods in too.

broccoli or spinach?

[dug_down_deep]

spinach

Back to Matty's: Rich Tea or Hob Nobs

(whatever that means)

[Anne]

Jaffa cakes. :p

hob nobs, then.

wheat or rye?

[Matty]

See, Anne speaks the lingo, and jaffa cakes is a damn good call IMO.

Rye prolly. it depends whats going on it really.


Hot Chocolate with brandy or Irish coffee?

[Anne]

hot chocolate with schnapps. Peppermint Schnapps. again, :p And not just because Schnapps is fun to say.

or else, Irish.

The boy gets a jaffa every day in his lunch box. :) I like good food where I can get it.

[miss djax]

both? :D

strawberry jam or grape jelly?

[Anne]

Strawberry FTW!

I forgot to post a choice!

Queen of Sheba or Lady Baltimore?

eta: Queen of Sheba:

http://www.exmsft.com/~ricks/images/des9404.jpg

Lady Baltimore:

http://farm1.static.flickr.com/22/113936308_a903264273_m.jpg

[dug_down_deep]

My queen.

Cheesecake, or homemade ice cream?

[Anne]

ice cream. Berry Bavarian. mmmmmm...

carrots or parsnips?

[miss djax]

carrots.

shallots or leeks?

[Anne]

leeks.

fennel or dill?

[miss djax]

dill

orzo or couscous?

[Anne]

ow.

Orzo. I'm Sicilian.

nectarines or peaches?

[miss djax]

peaches, only if they are white. then its nectarines ftw!

gravy or gastrique?

[Anne]

gravy all the way!

(except on fish)

(which type? ;))

links or patties?

[4321lynx]

Gravy. (Wot's gastrique?)

Ed: & links!!


Pont l'Évêque or Oka?

[Jobar]

Let's move this thread to the Games forum.

[Brianna]

Let's move this thread to the Games forum.

You forgot to choose! :D

[ofro]

like:

to move or not to move?

[BigEvil]

move

chicken fried steak or philly cheesesteak

[DMB]

Neither (veggie here).
Sweet or sour apple?

[4321lynx]

Gravy. (Wot's gastrique?)

Sweet apples ( If you call Granny Smiths, Spartans & Empire sweet.)

Somebody choose my submission above, repeated below!!! {hint - they are cheeses}



Pont l'Évêque or Oka?

..

[ofro]

Oka (based on the descriptions; never had either of them)

Old Camembert or old Limburger?

[DMB]

Camembert.

Macallan or Laphroiaig?

[hecaterin]

Laphroaig

(and whisky is so a food)

pasta puttanesca or bolognese?

[dug_down_deep]

I'm either not smart enough or not rich enough to play this game about 90% of the time.

Carry on.

[Notta]

I'm either not smart enough or not rich enough to play this game about 90% of the time.

Carry on.(Psst - use Wikipedia to look up the words.)

Pasta bolognese.

Free-range chicken or farm-raised fish?

[BigEvil]

chicken

pie or cake

[Notta]

The cake is a lie (http://www.squidoo.com/thecakeisalie), so I'll take the pie. (It even rhymes!)

Lemon meringue or Key Lime?

[sidhe]

Key Lime, ffs!

Strawberry shortcake or peach cobbler?

[Mediancat]

Strawberry shortcake, which I am eating even now.

Shoofly pie or fastnachts?

Rob

[hecaterin]

Shoofly pie.

Boston baked beans or English baked beans? (I'm making a sort of hybrid right now because I'm feeling experimental. Molasses AND tomato.)

[BigEvil]

Boston

New England clam chowder or Manhattan clam chowder

[dug_down_deep]

New England clam chowdah

lamb or venison?